The following Cumberland Valley Wrestlers went on to attain All-American Wrestling status in college. |
||||||
| Name | College | Place | Year | |||
| Division I All Americans | ||||||
| Randy Hoffman | Arizona St. | 7 th | 1979 | |||
| Ryan Williams | Old Dominion | 2 nd | 2009 | |||
| Zach Sheaffer | Pittsburgh | 8 th | 2009 | |||
| Division II All Americans | ||||||
| Jamie Thomas | Shippensburg | 4 th | 2004 | |||
| Jamie Thomas | Shippensburg | 6 th | 2005 | |||
| Jamie Thomas | Shippensburg | 2 nd | 2006 | |||
| Division III All Americans | ||||||
| Eric Vance | Amherst | 5 th | 1981 | |||
| National Christian College Championship All Americans | ||||||
| Randy Hoffman | Messiah | 1 st | 1975 | |||
| Randy Hoffman | Messiah | 1 st | 1977 OW | |||
| NAIA Championship All Americans | ||||||
| Randy Hoffman | Messiah | 4 th | 1977 | |||