Most wins in a season: 22 - Heckard
Most wins in an undefeated season: 19 - Smith
Most wins in a career: 250 - Humes
Most undefeated seasons: 4 - Humes
Most consecutive winning seasons: 18 - Humes
Most Sectional Champions in a season: 8 - Heckard
Most Sectional Champions in a career: 54 - Humes
Most District III Champions in a season: 4 - Smith & Barrick
Most Regional Champions in a season: 4 - Smith & Barrick
Most District III Champions in a career: 22 - Humes
Most Regional Champions in a career: 22 - Humes
Most PIAA Qualifiers in a season: 7 - Humes & Heckard
Most PIAA Qualifiers in a career: 45 - Humes
Most PIAA Place winners in a season: 4 - Barrick & Heckard
Most PIAA Place winners in a career: 18 - Barrick
Most PIAA Runner ups: 4 - Humes
Most PIAA Champions: 3 - Humes & Barrick
Most League Titles: 8 - Humes
Most consecutive years with a Sectional Champion: 12 - Humes
Most consecutive years with a District III Champion: 5 - Heckard
Most consecutive years with a Regional Champion: 5 - Heckard
Most consecutive years with a PIAA Qualifier: 15 - Humes
Most consecutive years with a PIAA Place winner: 4 - Humes (2x), Barrick & Heckard
Most times District III Team Champions: 3 - Barrick
Most times SC Regional Team Champions: 5 - Barrick
Highest team finish at PIAA Team Duals: 2 nd - Heckard
Highest team finish PIAA Individual States: 3 rd - Barrick & Heckard
Highest career winning percentage: 81% - Humes
Most 100 match winners coached: 9 - Heckard
Most Big 12-13-14 selections coached: 25 - Barrick
Most wins by a first year coach: 17 - Heckard
Most wrestlers selected Carlisle Sentinel all Stars in one season: 6 - Heckard
Highest wins per season average: 19 - Heckard